George Zimmerman Said “Fucking Cold” or “Fucking Punks” (updated)

by Dan Linehan on April 4, 2012

in Society

CNN Audio Expert

CNN has released an update today of what is said to be the clearest audio thus far of the George Zimmerman police call on February 26th.

It seems once the wind noise was isolated and removed, what was once thought to be a racial slur, “Fucking coons,” turned out to be actually much more benign.

According to CNN’s audio expert, it’s clear to him that George Zimmerman said it was “fucking cold” that evening.

Update 4/5:

CNN has released yet another enhanced sample of the recording.

According to Tom Owen and Zimmerman’s lawyers, Zimmerman said “fucking punks,” under his breath.

See more crime scene maps here..

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Hatteras propeller 11 pts

I am glad to found such useful post.

CapitanCaguama 5 pts

What an irresponsible and worthless journalist is this person. I can't believe that he presents this. First CNN "expert" saying that what you listen in on the tape is cold, when you can clearly hear that there's an s at the end of such word and then, the type of followup he does about the whole story, trying to portrait Trayvon as a criminal. Maybe this kid had some troubles, maybe he committed a crime, maybe not, but that's completely irrelevant to the case, he didn't deserved to be assassinated and he wasn't attacked because of whatever past he could have had, he was attacked for being there in that moment. Zimmerman harassed him even after the dispatch told him not to follow him. Zimmerman's argument is that Martin had something in his hand, and that Martin assaulted him first, now if Zimmerman was threatened by a can of coke and a bag of skittles, how would you feel if you were being followed by someone who might have a gun? What would have happened if the skin colors where opposite? If the person still standing was black, or the one in the floor was white, police would have made an arrest. Dan Linehan is a sorry excuse for a journalist and should be prevented from offering his nonsense as something other than a regular moron's coment.

ManfredMan 5 pts

 CapitanCaguama #1  Dude, News Flash! Zimmerman is not White! Look at the Man, Again Not White! Latino Yes!  Martin  was suspended from school and was only visting his Dad,  that was why Zimmerman was trying to find out what he was doing in that complex. Martin was a 6 foot 3" 17 yr. old big guy with tatoos on both arms and a Gold Grille with a Internet name of No Limit Nigga (not the picture you have seen on tv) , and was pissed when another guy confronted him about being in a place that he was visting caus he didnt recognize him. There had been Gangs dressed in Black Hoods that had been vandalizing the complex!  Remember he was staying with his dad while suspended from school.  I am sure Zimmerman asked him what he had in his Hand and i am sure Martin told him some skiddles and a Soft drink and then asked  the 6 foot 3 guy how old are you?. Get real! He probably attacked Zimmerman first and being frightened by a guy of his Martins stature defended himself, by pulling his gun and shooting him! Thats Bad and a shame for a Young Man do die that way but from all accounts Martin was no Choir boy either!  

markranger 92 pts

George Zimmerman Said “Fucking Cold” or “Fucking Punks” (updated)???   fucking cold..  really, that was considered.   This is not upstate new york or the mid-west.  People don't typically complain about going to florida and experiencing fucking cold weather.   What was it 50s (guess it could be relative)?   Sounds like no one is sure what he said.

rrrrottenapples 6782 pts

 markranger actually to a floridian, it would have been considered cold, it was 50's-60's, raining for most part all day, with a 5-10mph wind, granted i live in iowa, our version of cold would be a hell of alot colder, but to a floridian, it would have seemed cold to them

BertDilbert 2211 pts

 rrrrottenapples  markranger Get serious, Zimmerman just left the vehical headed off to see where Trayvon ran off to.  The last thing on his mind is whether it is cold or not.  The only thing on his mind at that point is getting Trayvon in view so that he can tell the cops where he is.  All considered, what he said was "these fuken boots", which were not the ideal footwear for following someone in tennis shoes.

rrrrottenapples 6782 pts

 BertDilbert  markranger honestly i could give a crap less what he was saying, i just know he didnt say fucking coons, nor did he say it in the presence of the no limit nigga, so to me it is totally irrelevant, i was just saying, that i cud see if he was saying fucking cold, i could understand why.

JuanMotie 26 pts

 BertDilbert

 Seems likely that Zimmerman stepping out of a warm SUV would say it's cold when it was low 60's, rainy and windy.

sexyoc 6 pts

 rrrrottenapples He said coons...at the end of coons you can hear a distinct "s" sound so I highly doubt he said "fucking colds" because that's just stupid

patti is ticked 7907 pts

 rrrrottenapples  markranger I wore a jacket that day.

patti is ticked 7907 pts

 markranger When I was in college, I sometimes waited table and tended bar...and I can tell you that indeed folks come here when we get a cold front and bitch, bitch, bitch...

tifosies 165 pts

 markranger The guy was pumped full of anger/adrenaline directed at that "f---ing pink/coon/goon" because "these a--holes, they always get away." He was not reflecting on the weather. period.

skeptykal_uv_everthang 1138 pts

 tifosies  

 

yeah, he was outraged, right? GZs voice on that 911 call was so pissed off and angry that you could hear his teeth clenching and his voice shaking in anger.

 

I kinda have to wonder what he sounds like when he's not mad... /sarc

skeptykal_uv_everthang 1138 pts

10:44 am.....BREAKING NEWS, CNN....

 

NO GRAND JURY IN THE TRAYVON MARTIN CASE

mfccfl 1780 pts

 skeptykal_uv_everthang 

 

Nice ta see that the Special Investigator did not bow to political pressure and relied on a evidence based decision  instead of on decision-based evidence.....

 

Tiff44 658 pts

 skeptykal_uv_everthang

 OH SHIT!  HERE WE GO!!!!  If Casey doesn't have him arrested, the shit will hit the f'n fan.

Tiff44 658 pts

 skeptykal_uv_everthang

 (Corey) not Casey, sorry!

mfccfl 1780 pts

 skeptykal_uv_everthang 

 

Just playing Devil's Advocate here....

 

<<<<<<<<<<<NO GRAND JURY IN THE TRAYVON MARTIN CASE>>>>>>>>>>>>>

 

I am assuming that means that the evidence is clear enough to make a case for or against GZ w/o a Grand Jury having to weigh the evidence..

 

While I am sure that this means there WON'T be an arrest, is it possible that there is some evidence heretofore unknown to the public that would all but prove GZ guilty of something??

 

skeptykal_uv_everthang 1138 pts

I think it means that they know that all the loopholes and technicalities that could be twisted and slanted in the SYG laws are too much for the average jurror to "weigh" over how they feel about in this situation. I also think it means that unless she got some absolutely DAMNING evidence from a new EYE witness or something, that she cannot bring charges in this case and make anything stick.

 

patti is ticked 7907 pts

 mfccfl  skeptykal_uv_everthang Everyone hates "Devil's Advocates" because most that claim that's what they're doing; when in reality thay are just trying to be rude and piss others off.  Now, a GENUINE attempt is okay with anyone.

mfccfl 1780 pts

 skeptykal_uv_everthang 

According to the Orlando Sentinel

 

"The decision {not to go to the Grand Jury) should not be considered a factor in the final determination of the case"

-State Attorney Office

 

 

sophistry2 13 pts

 skeptykal_uv_everthang grand juries are used as shields to not indict.

matthewjbutch 114 pts

 sophistry2  skeptykal_uv_everthang You don't understand the judicial system at all.

skeptykal_uv_everthang 1138 pts

 matthewjbutch 

I'm going to assume that your response to sophistry2  really didn't include me....???? I think I do, and I have no agreement with him/her at all on that statement.

matthewjbutch 114 pts

 skeptykal_uv_everthang  Yes, sorry, didn't  mean to include you. 

Tiff44 658 pts

I propose that two lives were lost that night with more to come.  While Martin was the only one carried away in a bodybag, Zimmerman's life is over too.  There is a bounty on his head, for God sakes.  If he goes to trial and is proven innocent, the activists and left sided media will raise such a stink that somebody will kill him before he can get out of the courtroom.  If there isn't enough evidence for a trial, then get ready for the anarchy to begin.  Not only will "vigilantes" (all hopped up on the shit they've been fed by the left) be after Zimmerman, but will be eager to take it out on whomever is accessable at the time, likely beginning with the less likely to defend themselves, working their way up to those of us who will, and it will get ugly.  Many lives will probably be lost.  The Trayvon supporters want justice, but not really...not if justice isn't what they think it should be.

oconnr 5 pts

 Tiff44

 It looks like you must be hopped up on some "shit that you've been fed by the left". Or some acid.  If you seriously believe that everyone is going to start killing one another over a verdict in court, you ma'am, are insane.

Tiff44 658 pts

You are a fucking idiot if you don't believe it'll happen.  It ALREADY IS!!!

oconnr 5 pts

@Tiff44 still waiting for your crazy theory to come to fruition.. I havent heard massive body counts on the news related to trayvon, and george zimmwrman is alive and well. Still white knuckled gripping your gun? Of course you are...

patti is ticked 7907 pts

 oconnr  Tiff44 Not at all nice-you don't know what Tiff or anyone else is doing, but come into here to make a stupid and snarky Libtarded comment.....FACTS have come out, which make all the THEORIES about Zimmerman saying "fucking punks" and "chasing TM down" look like the fish stories they are.

Whether Tiff or I, anyone here has a gun should not be of any concern to you. Nobody spends time "gripping" it....unless there is a really CLEAR and present danger,  To say what you did was just plain hostile and  WEIRD.

patti is ticked 7907 pts

 oconnr  Tiff44 Been around long enough to know Tiff44 is being realistic about that-history proves it.

patti is ticked 7907 pts

 Tiff44 They've already done that. So...I'm locked and loaded.

oconnr 5 pts

@patti is ticked @Tiff44 I see no realism in either of your posts. History has proven this happens? Like what, MLK? Apples to oranges.still waiting for your insane theory to take flight, tiff. I dont see thousands of people killing eachother over trayvon martin yet. George zimmerman is alive and well. Its people like you that really thought the world would end on dec 21st. Stop stewing over theoretical BS.

patti is ticked 7907 pts

 oconnr  patti  Tiff44 NOBODY asked you if your Libtarded ass saw any "realism in either of your posts." Zimmerman is alive, and as well as one can be under the circumstances; after being lied about, villified by a bunch of RACISTS.

mfccfl 1780 pts

Tweets show Trayvon Martin as a typical teen

http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/2012-04-09/news/mh-trayvon-tweets-040912-20120408_1_tweets-rap-music-slimm

 

If that's true... If TM's twits are "typical" amongst teenagers.....

 

Then that is just plain sad....

Conway193 1384 pts

 mfccfl Nah, just a typo - they meant "typical teenage thug".

Conway193 1384 pts

 zawy I listened to both renditions, over the same systems, repeatedly, approximately 200 times each. To me, it sounds like "fucking kungs" or "fucking kongs", at best. There seems to be a "GS" at the end of all, which eliminates ALL of the conjectures, from coon to cold, and definitely rules out punks.

 

Interestingly, there is a tribe of Bushmen in Africa called !Kung, but I doubt seriously if Zimmerman has ever heard of them. Further, even if Zimmerman knew of the !Kung, using the word as a pejorative toward Martin would have been ridiculous, as no one else, including Martin, would have understood the meaning - it would have been absurd - like cussing an English speaking Martin out - using Russian! Conversely, "Kong", i.e., "King Kong" has been used in the distant past as a ethnic slur directed toward blacks, though I seriously doubt Zimmerman knows that either.

 

At any rate, whatever Zimmerman said while leaving his vehicle has little or no bearing on the case anyway, even if he had called Martin a nigger, as his earlier remarks are totally irrelevant with regard to the alleged assault and the consequent shooting - Martin, wherever he was at the time, was not in the immediate vicinity, and could not possibly have heard anything Zimmerman said.

 

That's my take.

zawy 59 pts

 Conway193 Thanks for your feedback.  I only have to stretch my imagination a little to hear "kungs".  The K is a lot closer than the G.  Say most any word that ends in NS and you can hear and feel that the N ends in low frequencies right before it has to shift to the high frequencies of the S.  This stacatto change is what makes it possible to hear a G.   I suspect that if I found known NGS, GS, and/or NS words in his speech, we would be able to see and hear the difference.  My ear definitely hears "coons". 

MichaelSorg 6 pts

 zawy

 I can't imagine how anyone can hear "punks," especially someone who is an expert. Any linguists reading? As mentioned above,it is a nasal ending on the word, and if you listen to the entire recording, you will hear this sound over and over, especially in the word "somthin.'" This could be due in part to the fact that he is chewing gum or something similar during the call. A "P" could cause a slight distortion on a mic or phone, just as a "B" can, because they are explosive consonants which are formed with the lips, i.e., directly next to the microphone. But a "K" or hard "C" will not, because it is formed at the back of the throat, therefore no true expert could confound the two, and this word clearly begins with "K" or hard "C." Now for the middle of the word: clearly a long U sound as in "do" or "too," (phonetic symbol u:) not the short U sound in "fun" or "punks." (phonetic symbol ʌ) Back to the end of the word: if you pronounce "punks" yourself, you will see that the "N" sound is not drawn out. The K cuts it off; in fact, the N is almost dropped. So this can't be the pronounced drawn out nasal sound discussed above. The word is without a doubt: "Coon."

MichaelSorg 6 pts

 MichaelSorg

 One more point: this audio "improvement" by "experts" does nothing to improve the clarity. Especially the censoring bleep disturbs any chance of concentrated listening. Which leads me to believe it was intentionally disrupted, rather than improved. And the best recording which was found on YouTube has been withdrawn...hmmmm....and CNN was promoting this viewpoint? And the popup that comes during their clip: "EXPERT: SUSPECT WHISPERED `PUNKS``Didn't use racial slur before shooting teen" as well as the heading on CNN online: "Lawyers: Zimmerman whispered 'punks' before shooting Trayvon Martin" all present these statements in a way which can mislead. Contrast: "Lawyers claim Zimmerman whispered "punks", not "coons"

A correction to my post above: the word on the recording was plural, "coons."

Conway193 1384 pts

 MichaelSorg  zawy No, the word, without a doubt, is an unknown quantity, i.e., we don't know what the man said, period.

zawy 59 pts

 Conway193  MichaelSorg Finally, someone else is interested in what GZ said mainly because we have an interest in this area (phonemes/syllables), more than the overall shooting topic.  He also is approaching it from a completely different background of knowledge.  And yet we both say it is  "coons" based merely on the sound.  I can't say it is absolutely clearly different than "kongs" or  "goons", but only clearly different than kongs and only moderately distinguishable from goons.  Given the context that "coons" fits so perfect (chasing, gun in hand, a fast black kid at night) rather than running away from big fat white mobster types (goons), I'd say it's ridiculous to suggest there is any other possibility.  His anger in accenting the "C" in coons is what makes it sound a little bit like a "G".  "WE" don't know for sure what he said because some of us in the "WE" are in denial, or not familiar with southern vernacular.

patti is ticked 7907 pts

 MichaelSorg Those of that heard the actual police tape hear punks. The quality is fine on the original.

patti is ticked 7907 pts

 MichaelSorg  zawy No "oohh" sound. Kinda rules that out...

patti is ticked 7907 pts

 Conway193  MichaelSorg  zawy ya need a ooh sound for coons. There is none.

Conway193 1384 pts

 zawy Human beings are subjective creatures, which includes both of us, friend.

 

Fact is - I don't have a clue as to what Zimmerman said, and I don't think anyone else does either.

mfccfl 1780 pts

 Conway193  zawy 

<<<<At any rate, whatever Zimmerman said while leaving his vehicle has little or no bearing on the case anyway, even if he had called Martin a nigger, as his earlier remarks are totally irrelevant with regard to the alleged assault and the consequent shooting ->>>>

 

True...

But it likely *WOULD* make the case for the FBI's civil rights investigation.

As to that, unless there is ANY evidence that GZ has used racial slurs in the past, the civil rights case is as done a deal in GZ's favor as the self-defense case.

 

sophistry2 13 pts

Lots of people on the right are using this as proof that Zimmerman was in the right. They seem to be motivated more by disproving of people on the "liberal media" than about the big picture of what happened. Which is that an unarmed and uncriminal teenager was killed.

 

It does not matter if he said "fucking punks" or "fucking coons".

 

What matters is that he said "fucking --"

 

and also

 

"these assholes always get away"

 

I believe that is indicative of a vengeful mindset, and not one that is concerned as much about protecting property, but one that wants to get the guy once and for all. His neighbor, Franke Taafe, described Zimmerman as "fed up". 

 

Take what you will, but on some level such an emotional state likely makes him quicker to pull the trigger instead of shooting to wound or giving warning and holding at gunpoint. 

Conway193 1384 pts

 sophistry2 Oh bullshit, guy - Martin was beating the shit out of him and Zimmerman capped his ass - it's as simple as that.

SayItLikeItIs 735 pts

 Conway193  If only everyone could see things in black & white like you.  (no pun intended)

Previous post:

Next post: